| PL | Athlete | Team | Final |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Niedzwiecki, Aaron | Unattached | 42.20m |
| 2 | Norton, Brett | Merrillville TC | 37.11m |
| 3 | Stephenson, Newlyn | Merrillville TC | 36.39m |
| 4 | Pullins, Brad | Let It Fly Throwing | 35.00m |
| 5 | Kurlich, J P | Indys Racing Cheetahs | 26.54m |
| 6 | Collins, Benjamin | Body In Training TC | 24.68m |
| 7 | Flint, Zachary | Unattached | 22.82m |
| 8 | Ricci, Nathaniel | Let It Fly Throwing | 21.47m |
| 9 | Edwards, Eli | Columbus Running Club | 20.82m |
| 10 | Davis, Carter | White River Valley TC | 14.70m |
| 11 | Miller, Owen | Body In Training TC | 12.69m |
| Langevin, Ian | Indys Racing Cheetahs | ND | |
| Hunter, Aaron | Columbus Running Club | ND |